Epstein survivors have mixed feelings on Melania Trump's call for hearing in Congress

Epstein survivors have mixed feelings on Melania Trump's call for hearing in Congress

First Lady Melania Trump delivers a statement at the Grand Foyer of the White House on April 9, 2026, in Washington, D.C. Alex Wong/Getty Images
Following a shockwave-inducing public statement from First Lady Melania Trump—firmly denying any meaningful ties to Jeffrey Epstein and dramatically calling for a congressional hearing—survivors of the late sex offender’s abuse have responded with deeply divided reactions.
Speaking from the White House on Thursday, Trump declared she was not a victim of Epstein, had no knowledge of his crimes, and was never introduced to President Donald Trump by him. She then escalated the moment by urging Congress to take decisive action.
“Epstein was not alone,” she stated. “I call on Congress to provide the women who have been victimized by Epstein with a public hearing specifically centered around the survivors. Give these victims their opportunity to testify under oath in front of Congress.”
In a statement to NPR, the Department of Justice reaffirmed: “As we have always stated, we encourage any victims of Jeffrey Epstein — who wish to speak — to contact the FBI. Any survivor who has information on an abuser is encouraged to contact federal law enforcement.”
Later that same day, a coalition of 15 Epstein survivors fired back with a powerful statement, accusing the first lady of “shifting the burden” onto victims in order to shield powerful institutions—including the Department of Justice, law enforcement, prosecutors, and the Trump administration itself.
“Survivors of Jeffrey Epstein have already shown extraordinary courage by coming forward, filing reports, and giving testimony,” the statement read. “Asking more of them now is a deflection of responsibility, not justice.”
The White House did not immediately respond to NPR’s inquiries regarding the backlash or clarify why the first lady chose this moment to speak out.
Among the survivors who signed the statement was Marina Lacerda, identified in a 2019 indictment against Epstein as Minor-Victim 1. Shortly after the press conference, she posted a video on Instagram openly questioning whether such a hearing would produce any real results.
“You want to retraumatize us and ask us to go in front of Congress and tell them our story, which we have told some of them already,” Lacerda said. “And then do absolutely nothing.”
In a separate response, sisters Maria and Annie Farmer—both of whom have said they were abused by Epstein—called for “accountability, transparency, and justice.”
“If the federal government is truly committed to supporting survivors, it would ask us what we want and should follow the facts wherever they may lead,” their statement said.
Yet not all voices were critical. Alicia Arden, who says Epstein assaulted her in a hotel when she was a young model, told NPR she is ready—and willing—to testify. She also described Melania Trump’s statement as courageous.
“I’m willing to testify before Congress about what Jeffrey Epstein did to me and how I was attacked in the room,” Arden said.
The Justice Department has released millions of pages of documents tied to Epstein—detailing his personal life, connections, crimes, and inner circle. Within those files are multiple references to President Trump. However, an NPR investigation in February revealed that certain documents mentioning the president were initially withheld before some were later made public. To date, Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell remain the only individuals in the files to face criminal charges, despite numerous high-profile names being referenced.
Arden emphasized that “everything has always needed to come out” regarding the files, insisting the public deserves continued access to the truth. She added that whether other survivors choose to testify should remain entirely their decision.
“If they feel like it’s a burden to them, then they don’t have to,” Arden said. “I don’t feel like it’s a burden on me. It helps me to keep talking about it.”
Arden filed a police report before Epstein was indicted in 2006—a decision she now views as both terrifying and transformative.
“I was so scared, and I’m really happy that I did it because everyone’s happy that I did it now because it’s on file,” Arden said. “The other victims that didn’t get to do it, I did it for them.”
“I hope that we get to testify before Congress,” she added. “If Melania would like to be with us, I think that would be nice and helpful if we were… testifying next to her.”
The White House did not respond when asked whether the first lady would consider appearing alongside survivors.
Gloria Allred, an attorney who has represented 27 Epstein survivors—including Arden—said she welcomed the first lady’s statement but warned that survivors must not be compelled to testify.
“I don’t think any one survivor or even any one lawyer should decide this for everyone because there reportedly are over a thousand survivors,” Allred said. “It’s time for them to have control over their own decisions.”
Neither Allred nor Arden indicated they had been contacted by members of Congress regarding concrete plans for a hearing. Allred also urged Melania Trump herself to testify, calling it a “powerful example.”
“How many will be willing to testify if that hearing comes? I don’t know,” Allred said. “I don’t know if they can even feel that they can trust the system anymore.”
Meanwhile, lawmakers from both parties are rallying behind the first lady’s call for action.
California Rep. Robert Garcia, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee, said he supports holding a public hearing for Epstein’s victims and urged Committee Chairman James Comer to act immediately.
“We encourage Chairman Comer to respond to the First Lady’s request and schedule a public hearing immediately,” Garcia said.
Comer did not respond to NPR’s request for comment.
South Carolina Republican Rep. Nancy Mace praised the statement, declaring: “As a survivor, this isn’t political—it’s personal. And when the First Lady of the United States stands up and demands justice for Epstein’s victims, it is truly momentous.”
My Daughter-in-Law Gave Her Mother the Keys to My Late Wife’s Cabin Without My Permission. She Thought I Was Too Old to Fight Back—Until a County Officer Saw Her ID and Everything Changed. But the Real Shock Came When I Found the Files They Left Behind… 💔

“You’ll have to give up this property eventually, whether you like it or not,” my daughter-in-law’s mother declared as movers hauled her furniture into the cabin my late wife had built with her own hands. She had obtained a key, learned the gate code, and secured my daughter-in-law’s approval. The one person she hadn’t asked was me. I didn’t raise my voice or start an argument. Instead, I called for assistance and settled into my wife’s old rocking chair. Twenty-four minutes later, a county officer pulled up, glanced at the woman standing near my porch, and requested her identification. The moment he examined it, his entire demeanor changed.
That Saturday morning, I headed to the cabin intending to replace a single porch board that had begun to rot.
I certainly didn’t expect to find a rental truck parked against my front gate.
Two movers were carrying a mattress wrapped in protective plastic through the entrance of my home.
Near the walkway stood Phyllis, my daughter-in-law Lindsey’s mother, holding a clipboard and directing their every move.
I stopped at the foot of the porch.
“Would someone care to explain what’s happening here?”
Phyllis barely reacted to my arrival.
“Lindsey gave us the gate code and handed over a key,” she replied. “She said we could come in and settle ourselves.”
Without waiting for me to respond, she turned back to the workers.
“Please take that upstairs, into the bedroom on the left.”
Her complete disregard for my presence was almost more astonishing than the scene itself.
This wasn’t some abandoned cabin I had forgotten about or a property sitting unused for years.
My late wife, Layla, had planned every inch of that house.
For three years, she had worked over architectural sketches at our kitchen table, debated the smallest design choices, and personally stained the timber until it achieved the rich honey shade she had envisioned.
She had been gone for two years.
Even now, I made the drive from Asheville every few weeks because nowhere else brought me as close to her memory as that cabin.
Yet here I was, watching strangers move another family’s bedroom furniture into the home she had created.
Phyllis finally turned her attention back to me.
“Burton and I need somewhere to stay while we work through our problems in Asheville. Eventually, you’ll have to move on from this place anyway, Elton. We’re simply trying to make the best of the situation.”
I reached into my pocket, took out my phone, and contacted the appropriate local authorities.
For the first time, a hint of unease crossed Phyllis’s face.
“You really don’t have to involve anyone else,” she said. “This is a private family issue.”
“I own this property.”
I provided my name and the address, then explained exactly what I had discovered. I kept my voice steady and stuck to the facts.
When I finished, I ended the call.
I had no intention of wasting the morning arguing in my own driveway about whether I had the right to decide who could enter my house.
Instead, I walked along the porch and lowered myself into Layla’s old rocking chair.
Roughly ten minutes later, Lindsey emerged from the cabin holding a small decorative mirror I had never seen before.
She stopped short when she noticed me sitting there.
“Dad, I should’ve spoken to you first. I know that.”
“You gave your mother access to my property without even asking me.”
“Mom and Dad are going through a difficult time. I was only trying to help them. I honestly thought you wouldn’t have a problem with it.”
My eyes moved to the unfamiliar mirror resting against the porch railing.
“Well, you thought wrong.”
Twenty-four minutes after I had placed the call, a county vehicle appeared between the hemlock trees and pulled up beside the moving truck.
The officer climbed out.
Then his eyes landed on Phyllis.
He stopped walking.
It lasted only a moment, but the sudden pause was enough to draw everyone’s attention.
He took off his sunglasses.
“Ma’am.”
Phyllis stepped away from the porch, keeping her chin raised.
The officer requested her identification.
She handed him her card without hesitation.
He studied it, lifted his eyes toward her face, and examined the card once more.
His expression had grown noticeably more serious.
“Could you tell me exactly why you’re at this property today?”
Phyllis answered before anyone else could speak.
“We’re relatives. Elton hasn’t been himself since losing his wife, and we came here to help him.”
I rose from the rocking chair and faced the officer.
“This land belongs to me. I never authorized anyone to enter the cabin, move their belongings inside, or distribute my gate code.”
The officer shifted his attention to Lindsey.
“Did you give these individuals access to the property without the owner’s permission?”
Lindsey lowered her voice.
“I just assumed that because we’re family—”
The officer interrupted her explanation and instructed everyone to stop moving furniture until he could confirm the relevant details.
He returned to his vehicle and began making phone calls.
Twelve minutes went by.
The atmosphere on the porch grew increasingly uncomfortable, yet nobody seemed willing to break the silence.
Phyllis continued to hold herself with an air of confidence.
But she had stopped telling the movers what to do.
When the officer finally came back, the authority in his voice was unmistakable.
He directed Phyllis, her husband, and Lindsey to remove every item they had brought inside and leave the property.
Phyllis demanded an opportunity to speak with his superior.
“You can request that once you’ve left the premises,” he replied.
Within twenty-two minutes, they were gone.
Just before climbing into the truck, Phyllis turned around to look at me.
She offered a small, courteous smile.
It was almost friendly.
Somehow, that expression unsettled me far more than an angry outburst would have.
After the rental truck vanished down the gravel road, I stepped back inside the cabin.
Something about the place felt unfamiliar.
The comforting scent of Layla’s cedar oil had been replaced by an overpowering fragrance of artificial lavender.
Her clay pot was no longer sitting on the entry table where she had always kept it.
The four family photographs above the fireplace had disappeared.
In their place hung framed pictures of Lindsey and her relatives.
I climbed the stairs and entered our bedroom.
Layla’s blue-and-cream quilt had been taken off our bed and shoved into the closet.
Her reading room had suffered a similar intrusion.
The wooden box where she stored handwritten letters and birthday cards had been opened and emptied across the desk.
The contents hadn’t been carelessly scattered.
They had been arranged across the surface, as though someone had examined them one by one.
Someone had been searching through my wife’s private belongings.
I carefully returned each item to its proper place before carrying the box downstairs.
That was when I spotted three black contractor bags arranged in a straight line beside the gate.
I opened the first bag.
Inside lay Layla’s worn canvas jacket, her gardening shoes, and several of her favorite paperback books.
The second contained her clay pot and our wedding photograph.
The third held our wedding album.
I lowered myself onto the gravel, resting the album across my knees.
For several minutes, I couldn't bring myself to move.
Then my phone began ringing.
Ethan was calling.
“Dad, Lindsey’s really upset, and so is her mother. You had a county officer show up and treat them like they were complete strangers who had no business being there.”
I glanced at the three bags beside me.
“They packed your mother’s quilt into a garbage bag, Ethan. They did the same thing to our wedding album.”
Silence followed.
He had no immediate response.
“Come up here tomorrow,” I told him. “There are some things you need to see with your own eyes.”
That evening, I began putting Layla’s possessions back where they belonged.
While checking the guest room, I discovered four boxes the movers had apparently overlooked.
The first three contained ordinary household belongings.
The fourth was noticeably heavier than the others.
I opened it and found a collection of hanging file folders, each labeled in Phyllis’s unmistakably precise handwriting.
I removed the top folder and examined its tab.
The word written there made me pause.
ACCOUNT—
Whatever Phyllis had intended to accomplish at my cabin, she had left something behind that suggested her plans extended well beyond finding a temporary place to stay.
And my name was already part of a scheme I had never consented to.